Pamfilova, per TASS: saboteurs cut off 'four large regions'. Her commission, per Life.ru: two lines, back within an hour
Russia's election commission says Moscow's online voting platform is under a 'very powerful' cyberattack and that phone lines in the Far East were sabotaged. The reports we hold give two different sizes for the outage. None names an attacker, and none carries evidence beyond the officials' word.
The claim. On 19 September, the second day of the Duma vote, election commission chief Ella Pamfilova said Moscow's online voting platform had been under a cyberattack since the night before, and that it was still going on. Vedomosti, Life.ru, Regnum and Ukrainska Pravda all carry her words.
Two sizes for one outage. Both accounts come from the commission:
| Outlet | What it reports | Source it gives |
|---|---|---|
| TASS | saboteurs left 'four large regions' without connectivity | Pamfilova |
| Life.ru | two trunk lines down, Sakhalin and Khabarovsk Krai, restored 'within an hour' | the commission |
| The Insider | sabotage 'in a number of regions'; broadcasts cut at 'several polling stations' | Rostelecom |
How it is worded. Ukrainska Pravda adds 'allegedly' ('нібито') in Ukrainian and 'has claimed' in English. Life.ru and Regnum state the attack in the officials' words, without hedging.
'Normal' comes from officials too. Life.ru, Interfax and Regnum report that voting ran 'normally' ('штатно'). Each attributes that word to the commission or to the Moscow observers' headquarters. More than 2.8 million people had voted in Moscow by mid-day two, about 2.5 million of them electronically, say Moscow's election commission and the observers' headquarters.
What is not settled. - Who attacked. No report names anyone. - Whether four regions or two lines went down. - Whether any votes were affected. Only officials say none were. - No independent check of the platform appears in any report we hold.
What this is about. Russia is electing its parliament, and the body running the vote says someone attacked it while people were voting.
How it got here. The State Duma is the lower house of Russia's parliament. It has 450 seats and is elected every five years. This year the vote runs over three days and ends on Sunday 20 September. Three-day voting was brought in during the 2020 pandemic and kept afterwards.
Moscow has let voters cast ballots online since an experiment in 2019. Voters use the city portal mos.ru, or electronic terminals at polling stations. Critics of the system, including opposition politicians and independent observers, have said for years that online votes are harder to check than paper ballots. Officials say the system is secure. That argument is not settled.
This is the first Duma election since Russia began its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. The war itself began in 2014. Since 2022 most of Russia's prominent opposition figures have been jailed, have died or have left the country. Many outlets that report Russia critically now work from abroad.
Who is involved. Ella Pamfilova has chaired Russia's Central Election Commission since 2016. The commission runs the vote and announces the results. The Moscow Public Headquarters for election observation is an official body. It speaks for the city's observers, and it reported the attack too. Rostelecom is Russia's state-controlled telecoms operator. It runs many of the lines that carry the polling-station video broadcasts.
What is at stake. If the attack happened as officials describe it, it is an attempt to disrupt a national election. If its size is overstated, it could be used to explain away problems at polling stations or in the online count. Either way, the only account we hold comes from the officials running the vote.
Where it stands. Officials say the attack is still going on and that voting has not been affected. No report names an attacker.
What is being argued about
- Pamfilova says Moscow's online voting platform is under a continuing cyberattack
- Four regions cut off, or two trunk lines restored within an hour
- Only the officials running the vote say voting went 'normally'
- More than 2.8 million Moscow votes by mid-day two, about 2.5 million of them online
Claims and verdicts
Памфилова: продолжается кибератака на московскую платформу ДЭГ
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Vedomosti →
What we have measured
Actor named names Russia as the state actor, not the company, and frames it neutrally ×1Asserted vs attributed the headline attributes the attacks to Novak ×1Asserted vs attributed Attributes the attack count to Novak in the headline. ×1Attribution figure stated flat with no source named, and tied to 2027 ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
L
Life.ru
Московская платформа ДЭГ остаётся под мощной кибератакой, заявила Памфилова
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Life.ru →
What we have measured
Absence of notice framed as a finding a booking agent not having heard is put in the headline as the news ×1Absence used as rebuttal a booking service's lack of notice is run as a counter-report, sourced anonymously ×1Actor framing The company is the only actor named. The regulator appears only as a law it obeys. ×1Actor label Calls the Ukrainian president the head of a 'regime' ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
R
Regnum
Памфилова: кибератака на московскую платформу ДЭГ продолжается
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
U
Ukrainska Pravda
Russia reports major cyberattack on Moscow's electoral system
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Ukrainska Pravda →
What we have measured
Actor named shortages are described with no one named as causing them ×1Actor named The cancellation is pinned on a named Hungarian official's refusal. ×1Actor named The town is called 'occupied', but the lede does not name who occupies it or who blocks aid. ×1Actor named Names the EU and partners as the ones paying ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
U
Ukrainska Pravda
У Росії поскаржилися на масштабну кібератаку на виборчу систему Москви
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Ukrainska Pravda →
What we have measured
Actor named shortages are described with no one named as causing them ×1Actor named The cancellation is pinned on a named Hungarian official's refusal. ×1Actor named The town is called 'occupied', but the lede does not name who occupies it or who blocks aid. ×1Actor named Names the EU and partners as the ones paying ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
R
Regnum
ОШ Москвы: наблюдаем атаку на ДЭГ, она не влияет на процесс голосования
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
I
Interfax
В голосовании на выборах в Москве приняли участие более 2,8 млн человек
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Interfax →
What we have measured
A checkable claim passed on unchecked relays the president's statistic about world cities in quotation marks with no check and no counter-voice ×1A denial carried as characterisation press reports are labelled planted, and the label is passed on in the report's own voice ×1Anonymous source The meetings are sourced to unnamed people familiar with the situation. ×1Anyone hurt named or counted injuries described in clinical detail; the man is never named ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
Central Election Commission views sabotage in Far East as attempt to disrupt elections
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at TASS →
What we have measured
Accusation carried by a verb of fact 'Noted' presents a Russian diplomat's accusation of terror as an observation. Kyiv gives no response anywhere in the text. ×1Accusation carried unhedged a charge of terror against civilians is introduced with 'noted', which treats it as fact, and nobody answers it ×1Actor named Ukrainian forces are named as acting, in the report's own voice ×1Actor named Names 'the Western community' as the actor, in Putin's words ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
L
Life.ru
Спиленная опора и повреждённый кабель: ЦИК сообщил о двух диверсиях во время выборов
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Life.ru →
What we have measured
Absence of notice framed as a finding a booking agent not having heard is put in the headline as the news ×1Absence used as rebuttal a booking service's lack of notice is run as a counter-report, sourced anonymously ×1Actor framing The company is the only actor named. The regulator appears only as a law it obeys. ×1Actor label Calls the Ukrainian president the head of a 'regime' ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
T
The Insider
«Ростелеком» сообщил о диверсии на линиях связи в ряде регионов во время выборов. Трансляция на нескольких участках временно прервалась
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at The Insider →
What we have measured
Absolute figure The only report that gives the amount in roubles ×1Absolute figure given gives the total in roubles, which lets a reader check the percentage ×1A closed door exchange reported flat a refusal inside a private meeting is asserted in the headline with no source named in the text we hold ×1Actor named The headline names the president as the one who acted, and adds the plant's profit and the new manager's family tie ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
В голосовании на выборах в Москве приняли участие более 2,8 млн человек
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Interfax →
What we have measured
A checkable claim passed on unchecked relays the president's statistic about world cities in quotation marks with no check and no counter-voice ×1A denial carried as characterisation press reports are labelled planted, and the label is passed on in the report's own voice ×1Anonymous source The meetings are sourced to unnamed people familiar with the situation. ×1Anyone hurt named or counted injuries described in clinical detail; the man is never named ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
R
Regnum
МГИК: в голосовании в Москве приняли участие более 2,8 млн человек
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
R
Regnum
2,5 миллиона человек приняли участие в электронном голосовании в Москве
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
Who wrote it
Coverage, outlet by outlet
Central Election Commission views sabotage in Far East as attempt to disrupt elections
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at TASS →
What we have measured
Accusation carried by a verb of fact 'Noted' presents a Russian diplomat's accusation of terror as an observation. Kyiv gives no response anywhere in the text. ×1Accusation carried unhedged a charge of terror against civilians is introduced with 'noted', which treats it as fact, and nobody answers it ×1Actor named Ukrainian forces are named as acting, in the report's own voice ×1Actor named Names 'the Western community' as the actor, in Putin's words ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
— state-controlled
«Ростелеком» сообщил о диверсии на линиях связи в ряде регионов во время выборов. Трансляция на нескольких участках временно прервалась
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at The Insider →
What we have measured
Absolute figure The only report that gives the amount in roubles ×1Absolute figure given gives the total in roubles, which lets a reader check the percentage ×1A closed door exchange reported flat a refusal inside a private meeting is asserted in the headline with no source named in the text we hold ×1Actor named The headline names the president as the one who acted, and adds the plant's profit and the new manager's family tie ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
— exile
У Росії поскаржилися на масштабну кібератаку на виборчу систему Москви
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Ukrainska Pravda →
What we have measured
Actor named shortages are described with no one named as causing them ×1Actor named The cancellation is pinned on a named Hungarian official's refusal. ×1Actor named The town is called 'occupied', but the lede does not name who occupies it or who blocks aid. ×1Actor named Names the EU and partners as the ones paying ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
— independent
Russia reports major cyberattack on Moscow's electoral system
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Ukrainska Pravda →
What we have measured
Actor named shortages are described with no one named as causing them ×1Actor named The cancellation is pinned on a named Hungarian official's refusal. ×1Actor named The town is called 'occupied', but the lede does not name who occupies it or who blocks aid. ×1Actor named Names the EU and partners as the ones paying ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
— independent
В голосовании на выборах в Москве приняли участие более 2,8 млн человек
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Interfax →
What we have measured
A checkable claim passed on unchecked relays the president's statistic about world cities in quotation marks with no check and no counter-voice ×1A denial carried as characterisation press reports are labelled planted, and the label is passed on in the report's own voice ×1Anonymous source The meetings are sourced to unnamed people familiar with the situation. ×1Anyone hurt named or counted injuries described in clinical detail; the man is never named ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
МГИК: в голосовании в Москве приняли участие более 2,8 млн человек
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
Памфилова: продолжается кибератака на московскую платформу ДЭГ
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Vedomosti →
What we have measured
Actor named names Russia as the state actor, not the company, and frames it neutrally ×1Asserted vs attributed the headline attributes the attacks to Novak ×1Asserted vs attributed Attributes the attack count to Novak in the headline. ×1Attribution figure stated flat with no source named, and tied to 2027 ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
ОШ Москвы: наблюдаем атаку на ДЭГ, она не влияет на процесс голосования
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
Спиленная опора и повреждённый кабель: ЦИК сообщил о двух диверсиях во время выборов
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Life.ru →
What we have measured
Absence of notice framed as a finding a booking agent not having heard is put in the headline as the news ×1Absence used as rebuttal a booking service's lack of notice is run as a counter-report, sourced anonymously ×1Actor framing The company is the only actor named. The regulator appears only as a law it obeys. ×1Actor label Calls the Ukrainian president the head of a 'regime' ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
Московская платформа ДЭГ остаётся под мощной кибератакой, заявила Памфилова
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Life.ru →
What we have measured
Absence of notice framed as a finding a booking agent not having heard is put in the headline as the news ×1Absence used as rebuttal a booking service's lack of notice is run as a counter-report, sourced anonymously ×1Actor framing The company is the only actor named. The regulator appears only as a law it obeys. ×1Actor label Calls the Ukrainian president the head of a 'regime' ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
2,5 миллиона человек приняли участие в электронном голосовании в Москве
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—
Памфилова: кибератака на московскую платформу ДЭГ продолжается
Open this report in The AI Times →
Read it at Regnum →
What we have measured
Actor label Calls Ukraine's president the head of a regime in the report's own voice. ×1Actor named names Ukraine's forces as the attacker of the town ×1Actor named Ukraine's armed forces are named outright as the side attacking the town ×1Actor named Names the organiser and says he is under arrest ×1
Outlet profile in The AI Times →
—